Mortgage
Headline Mortgage Numbers Can Hide Real Problems, Sales Executive Argues
By Real Estate Wire Staff, . Real Estate Wire.
Strong volume numbers can cover a lot of sins in a mortgage sales operation. Bryan Lovell, Vice President of Sales at Highland Mortgage, argues in a HousingWire column that most managers are not looking far enough beneath them.
Lovell lays out two scenarios where top-line figures pointed managers in the wrong direction, and explains what a deeper look at the data revealed.
The branch that looked broken but wasn't
The first involves a branch whose overall conversion rate, meaning the share of leads that made it to closing, sat well below the company average. That is the kind of number that typically triggers a coaching conversation about closing skills.
When Lovell broke the data down by credit bucket, a grouping of borrowers by credit score range, a different picture emerged. The branch was converting high-credit-score borrowers at the same rate as the rest of the company. What dragged the headline figure down was the mix: a disproportionate share of their leads came from lower-credit-score borrowers and applicants without a qualifying credit score, both of which are harder to close. The branch did not have a conversion problem. It had a lead-mix problem, and those require different fixes.
The practical point Lovell makes is that a coaching conversation built on the wrong diagnosis can make things worse. Telling a loan officer to close harder when the real issue is funnel composition sends them after the wrong variable.
Lovell also notes that within the credit-bucket analysis, some loan officers had left meaningful revenue on the table by converting their best-qualified borrowers below the company average. That is a different conversation, one about whether the officer is acting as an advisor or simply directing a well-qualified borrower to a website. As Lovell puts it, "a high-credit-score borrower knows who they are, and they also know they can get a loan anywhere."
The top producer with a hidden leak
The second case is harder to raise with the person involved. Lovell describes a top-1-percent originator, a perennial President's Club winner with thousands of five-star reviews, who posted strong year-over-year volume and unit growth. Every number at the surface looked good.
The explanation for the volume growth was straightforward: the producer was getting significantly more leads than the year before. More opportunities, more closings. When Lovell looked at pre-qualification-to-lock conversion, meaning the share of pre-qualified borrowers who went on to lock in a mortgage rate (an earlier step in the process than reaching a funded loan), that rate had declined compared with the same period the prior year.
Some of the additional opportunities were slipping away before a rate lock, a leak the raw volume numbers made invisible. Lovell draws a comparison to 2020 and 2021, when the refinance boom let inefficiencies hide under sheer production volume, and argues the same dynamic can operate at the individual producer level whenever business is running hot.
What managers should take from this
The column is opinion from a sales executive at one lender, not a market-wide study, and the case studies are illustrative rather than statistically representative. Lovell does not provide data on how common either pattern is across the industry, or what a typical gap looks like between surface conversion and credit-bucket-adjusted conversion.
The underlying argument is straightforward: if you are managing loan officers on headline conversion rates alone, you may be coaching the wrong thing. Credit-bucket segmentation can show whether a conversion gap reflects a skill problem or a lead-quality problem. Pre-qualification-to-lock rates can show whether a producer's pipeline is as healthy as their closed-loan count suggests.
What remains unresolved is how widespread either pattern is. Lovell's cases are drawn from his own data at one lender, and whether the same gaps appear broadly across the industry is a question his column does not answer.
Source: https://www.housingwire.com/articles/funnel-metrics-lo-conversion/
Real Estate Wire provides news and information, not real estate, legal, or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your specific needs.