Mortgage
Mortgage Lenders Face a Real Choice on Credit Scoring for the First Time in Decades
By Real Estate Wire Staff, . Real Estate Wire.
For the first time in decades, mortgage lenders have a real choice in credit scoring, and the window to prepare is narrowing. That is the central message from Patrick Tynan, Chief Sales Officer at Advantage Partners Solutions, in a conversation published by HousingWire.
What changed
VantageScore 4.0 is already accepted on most loans sold to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and the Federal Housing Administration begins accepting it on January 1. Tynan describes the shift as one of the biggest he has seen in his career. The model incorporates trended data, meaning it can score borrowers with thin credit files or those who have worked to rebuild their credit, potentially bringing more buyers into the market without, as Tynan puts it, "anyone lowering the bar."
The Federal Housing Finance Agency has also signaled it is looking at both the credit report requirement and loan-level pricing, which Tynan says lenders should read as a signal that further change is coming, and likely soon.
Where lenders should be careful
The cost-savings conversation has pushed some lenders toward pulling fewer credit bureaus, a move Tynan argues is a false economy. "Saving a few dollars by seeing less of the borrower is not a good trade," he said. His recommendation is to adopt VantageScore 4.0 while keeping the tri-merge credit report, which draws from all three bureaus.
The metric that matters, he argues, is not the cost of a single credit pull but the cost per funded loan. Because roughly one in five pulls results in a closed loan, optimizing around the per-pull price can obscure where money is actually being lost or saved. Lenders doing heavy purchase business with frequent preapprovals operate differently from those with strong pull-through rates, and pricing structures should reflect that.
What a credit partner should actually do
Tynan, who managed teams at Wells Fargo and Countrywide before moving to the vendor side, draws a sharp line between a credit provider and a strategic partner. A vendor delivers a report. A partner, in his framing, explains what a new rule means for a specific shop, delivers scores from all three bureaus without forcing a technology overhaul, and picks up the phone when a rescore is holding up a closing.
Advantage Partners Solutions describes itself as one of the five largest credit resellers in the country by revenue and says its privately held structure, rather than private equity or public ownership, lets it move on client needs rather than quarterly earnings cycles. The firm also offers verification services, flood certifications and quality control products alongside credit reporting.
What to watch
Tynan expects multiple score options to become standard practice within a few years, with nontraditional data such as rent payments feeding into scoring models over time. Cost pressure, he says, is not going away alongside that expansion.
The practical implication for lenders is straightforward: the technology, investor relationships and mortgage insurance partnerships that need to be ready for VantageScore 4.0 also need to be ready for FICO 10T when it arrives. Lenders who wait for a final rule before starting that work are likely to find themselves behind when the next announcement lands.
Source: https://www.housingwire.com/articles/vantagescore-4-mortgage-credit-strategy/
Real Estate Wire provides news and information, not real estate, legal, or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your specific needs.